Elsinore is in theaters on Nov. 20.
Another award season, another Shakespeare-adjacent film starring a well-liked actor who is apparently overdue for their state mandated awards campaign. Yes, since Jessie Buckley soared straight to an Oscar win last year for playing the Bard’s long-suffering wife Agnes in Chloé Zhao’s pretty good historical drama Hamnet, apparently it’s now time for another thespian to make a claim for the throne. This time it’s the ever-reliable Andrew Scott — an actor I’m never mad to see pop up in anything — working with director Simon Stone, who I’ve never had a strong opinion about one way or the other. The Swiss-born Australian filmmaker claims a profound love for Shakespeare’s works, so it makes sense for him to jump at the chance to direct a movie about a man who would do anything to make his mark playing Hamlet before he dies. If only such passion had also managed to conjure up a good reason for the film to exist.
Elsinore, named for the castle where the events of the play Hamlet take place, stars Scott as Scottish actor Ian Charleson, an actor most famous for his work in 1981’s Chariots of Fire and for later succumbing to AIDS after his National Theatre run as Hamlet in late 1989. The film dramatizes Charleson’s battle with the disease while under the care of Margaret Johnson (Olivia Colman), one of the UK’s earliest specialists in treating HIV/AIDS. Charleson’s drive to play the Prince of Denmark knowing he will most likely die in the process is as relatable and unerringly human as many of the dramatic impulses present in the play’s cast of characters. But the film’s construction — the pieces that are supposed to make it compelling as a visual story — short-change that emotional core more often than it can endure.
For a movie about a man dying of AIDS, Elsinore is far too blandly amiable. Charleson’s malaise with the results of his acting career and polite contempt for the smattering of fame he’s received are a good place to start, but he’s surrounded by too many good-natured and dramatically vacant supporting characters who basically exist to tell him he’s strong for toughing it out. Billie Piper is on hand as Patsy, Charleson’s token straight friend who offers him soup and smiles, and Johnny Flynn plays Richard Eyre, Charleson’s director who is only too understanding that his leading man may just collapse and die mid-performance. Even Colman’s Johnson, who routinely scolds Charleson for putting Hamlet ahead of his health, is tuned to more of an annoyance than an antagonist. Colman can trade barbs with the best of them, but there’s never any doubt that her Very Concerned resolve will ultimately melt in the face of Charleson’s peppy determination to make his eight o’clock curtain.
Elsinore may have a lot of drama on the stage, but it’s severely lacking in such on the page.
The only person who actually challenges Charleson is Derek Jarman (David Dawson), the man who directed Charleson in the 1978 film, Jubilee. A fellow artist living with HIV, Jarman thinks Charleson is a sell-out for not living openly as a gay man and continuing to work with queer artists, and that Charleson’s desire for mainstream appeal is a disservice to the generation of gay men who are dropping like flies from the disease they share. Charleson’s rebuke that he doesn’t owe his life choices to anyone but himself, that he considers himself an actor more than an AIDS patient, is not only one of the film’s best scenes but also one of the only moments where Stephen Beresford’s screenplay depicts its subject as anything more than a summary. Elsinore may have a lot of drama on the stage, but it’s severely lacking in such on the page.
For his part, Scott is very good here. His precise but unfussy inhabitation of Charleson’s doomed conviviality is the number one reason to see Elsinore, and it will almost assuredly get him into the awards conversation as everyone involved intended. The way Scott manages to convey softly spoken but biting remarks as a critical point of character rather than an obtrusive affectation is commendable, as is his tenderness with the other patients that never belies false hope in their odds of survival. The scenes of Charleson rehearsing his lines and finding how he will channel his frustrations and anxieties into his performance as Hamlet are among the moments where the film really does come alive.
Sadly, Stone’s direction doesn’t do much to back Scott up. The flat colors and coherent but uninspired cinematography is all in service of not getting in the way of his actors’ legibility. It’s a noble goal, but it makes the film anonymous on a formal level. Nor does it matter when the edit undermines Scott’s work; Stone chops up important scenes, including Charleson on the stage, as montages instead of letting them actually play out. I don’t understand why you would hire a lead actor with years of theater experience — including a run playing Hamlet — and not just let him play Hamlet. That we don’t get five to ten uninterrupted minutes of just seeing Scott as Charleson giving his final performance — the one the movie has spent its whole runtime insisting is so important — is such a bizarre choice that I simply sat there confused as the credits rolled.
